The secret garden in 2014, three years before it was razed. Photo: Photo: © Daryl-Ann Saunders (https://linktr.ee/DASaunders)

The Bushwick community is fighting back against a proposed high-rise development planned for the former site of a beloved community garden, with eagle-eyed neighbors discovering part of the plan is in fact illegal.

The corner of Broadway and Linden St. — once a community garden opening into a lush green space known as The Secret Garden — is set to be turned into a development with a 20-story building complex and a parking lot for 114 cars, according to public filings.

The development is “as of right,” which means no community input is legally required.

The planned development. Image: Leonard Fusco / DOB public filings screenshot

However, since news of the 20-story plans spread through Bushwick, residents looking to fight the development have uncovered a deed restriction on the site that could stall construction.

The deed restriction — which goes back to when the city owned the land — states that an area the developer currently has earmarked for a parking lot is in fact legally required to be an “open space.”

At a Community Board 4 meeting on the issue last Thursday, Councilmember Antonio Reynoso’s Legislative and Land Use Director Asher Freeman said his office had a meeting with NYC’s Department of Buildings (DOB) and Economic Development Corporation (EDC), and both agencies agreed a carpark would be an “inappropriate use of the space” and a “violation.”

The site at Broadway and Linden St. on Jan. 25. Photo: Jessy Edwards for BK Reader.

He said the EDC had sent a letter to the Manhattan-based developer Ekstein Development last Wednesday, advising them their plans were not legal. They were yet to hear back.

“These folks tend to hide behind a huge legal team and I wouldn’t be surprised if they’re conferring with lawyers on how they want to respond,” Freeman said. “But I was made pretty clear about the state of play: If the developer is not responsive, we fully expect the city to take it to court and litigate this.”

The building seen alongide the Gates Ave. station. Image: Leonard Fusco / DOB public filings screenshot

Ekstein was invited to respond to the community at the meeting on Thursday, but did not reply to invitations sent by the board or Reynoso’s office, and did not send a spokesperson.

The deed restriction should send them back to the drawing board, if they are to proceed legally. Freeman said the development was required to have a certain amount of parking because of its size. This restriction will either force it to replan the parking for underground — at great expense — or to rethink the size of the high-rise itself.

Ekstein Development did not respond to the BK Reader‘s request for comment.

The discovery was a win for community members who felt let-down by the fact Bushwick’s current zoning even allows for a building of this size. The community worked on a Bushwick Community Plan for six years that would have rezoned the neighborhood and slowed gentrification.

However the plan was thrown out by Mayor Bill de Blasio’s office, which called it a “downzoning.”

Community Board 4 Chairperson Robert Camacho said the deed restriction gave them the “upper hand.” “Nobody can tell us it’s too late, it’s never too late. We gonna make sure we get what we deserve. And we need to put pressure on the next mayor for the community plan.”

Representatives for the EDC, Brooklyn Borough President Eric Adams, NY State Senator Julia Salazar and NYC Comptroller Scott Stringer also attended the meeting.

The development stretches in between the row houses. Image: Leonard Fusco / DOB public filings screenshot

A tower on the Secret Garden

Ekstein Development has filed plans for a 205-foot building on Broadway and Linden Street, housing 106 residential units, commercial space and a community facility. 

Its proposed Z-shaped development stretches into the leafy area between the rows of mostly three-story brownstones of Linden and Grove Streets, formerly known as The Secret Garden at Linden-Bushwick Community Garden.

In its current plans, that area — which is in fact protected by the deed — would be turned into an attended parking lot for 114 cars with stackers, and an open space for residents of the 20-story building, filings show.

Avellar G. Hansley profiled for the ‘Pioneers of Bushwick’ series. Photo: © Daryl-Ann Saunders. See Instagram / Facebook

For more than 30 years, the site was a community hub, founded by late community leader Avellar G. Hansley in 1981 and renamed in her honor in 2014.

Hansley was remembered at the Community Board 4 meeting Thursday, with her daughter Kristal Hansley attending, and vowing to fight the development.

The younger Hansley is the first Black woman to launch a national community solar company.

“I will be bringing the heat and a lot of green organizations to this fight,” she said. “We’re not going down like this. It shows that the developer isn’t here. It shows how much they really care.”

The meeting also raised questions about how developments are able to go ahead without community notification. Freeman said there was not requirement for the DOB to notify communities of plans being filed, but he would be interested to hear if people want that changed.

Honoring Avellar G. Hansley in The Secret Garden, Aug. 2, 2014. Photo: © Daryl-Ann Saunders

Linden Street resident Alan Gamboa was one of the eagle-eyed residents who first brought the development to the attention of the community, after finding the developer’s plans filed on the DOB website.

He vowed to fight the development in whatever way the community has available, from the deed restriction, to zoning, to protests at the site and at the Ekstein Development offices in Manhattan.

$
$
$

Your contribution is appreciated.

Make a Donation

BK Reader is brought to you for free daily. Please consider supporting independent local news by making a donation here. Whether it is $1 or $100, no donation is too big or too small!

Jessy Edwards

Jessy Edwards is a freelance writer based in Bushwick. Originally from New Zealand, she has written for the BBC, Rolling Stone, NBC New York, CNBC and her hometown newspaper, The Dominion Post, among others.

Join the Conversation

5

  1. Parking should e below the building. Our city needs more greenspace not less. It would be good for everyone.
    I am so glad they found this out. It makes more sense.
    This concrete and glass jungle needs some green.

  2. It is a fight to be ongoing. The hight at 20 stories is so out of proportion to the neighberhood. This site before the garden was a 4 story building called Tells. It was our little Macy’s in Bushwick. This part of Bushwick had great shopping and many stores and 4 movie theaters in the 3 blocks from this location.. This was my neighberhood as I lived up the block on Bushwick Avenue in a house built in 1920. To let this out of kilter building go forward would be a travesty. The first A and P opened in 1955 on Goodwin place around the corner and we had 4 banks within 3 blocks and you could not find a better area than my Bushwick. On Bushwick avenue they tore down a Queen Anne house to put up another out of character building. Sad to see and DeBlasio is aware of it but his nose is out of joint. Soldier on those of you who now live there. Keep up the good fight.

  3. We long time Blacks & Latinos should’ve Pushed-Back against the GENTRIFICATION of Bushwick, Bedstuy, and Other Black & Brown Communities that are Now being both Coveted & Enjoyed by people who look Nothing like those whom had to survive and outlive the pain, danger, and savagery of the drug epidemic, yet have to watch “Others” enjoy the Benefits of the Restructuring and Redevelopment of the same “Opposite” neighborhoods that “Redlining” forced us into…
    ????????

  4. I have corrections that I hope will be incorporated into the article out of respect. The lot on the corner (minus the parking lot on the side) was the Linden-Bushwick Block Association Garden, later renamed in honor of founder Avellar Hansley. Hidden from street view and connected via a ramp was the landlocked space that came to be known as the Secret Garden. (Out of respect, when writing about the projects and events that were going on there, the full name of “The Secret Garden at Linden-Bushwick Community Garden” was used.)
    The new high-rise would sit on the corner/garden lot; the Secret Garden (which is the 19,000 square feet protected in the deed), is where they want to put a parking lot (and open the remaining area to the public).
    I volunteered at the Linden-Bushwick Community Garden for several years and led the Secret Garden project which started as an ecological restoration, and led to working with hundreds of volunteers to create a community farm and nature preserve.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *