Photo: Newyork10r at English Wikipedia

Brooklyn property owners say they’ve been blindsided by a law that requires them to have a city gas inspection by Dec. 31, or else risk being slapped with a large fine.

Local Law 152 of 2016 says most building owners and places of worship in community boards 1, 3 and 10 of all boroughs must have their gas piping systems inspected by a Licensed Master Plumber by the end of the year. Only one- and two-family homes are exempt. And those who don’t file for Inspection Certification by Dec. 31 may face a $10,000 penalty.

In Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn Community Board 3 District Manager Henry Butler said property owners had been left scrambling due to receiving “literally no notification at all” from the Department of Buildings (DOB) about the upcoming deadline.

Henry L. Butler, Brooklyn Community Board 3 District Manager. Photo: Supplied / Henry Butler

How we found out about it was because, back in October, private plumbers started sending out notices to homeowners soliciting business, saying, ‘If you do not get this inspection done the city will fine you $10,000.'”

He said residents started calling the community board asking if it was a scam. The board contacted the DOB, which told them the plumbers were correct. “We were like, ‘Huh? When were you gonna tell us?'”

Local Law 152 was brought in after the deadly Second Avenue gas pipe explosion of 2015. The explosion was caused by an illegal gas line fitted by an unlicensed plumber.

This is the first year of the law being enforced. The DOB plans to cycle through different community district numbers each year over a four year rotation to cover the whole city.

This year, Brooklyn property owners and church, synagogue and mosque leaders in Greenpoint, Williamsburg, Bed-Stuy, Bay Ridge, Dyker Heights and Fort Hamilton are under obligation. In 2021, building owners in community boards 2, 5, 7, 13 and 18 in all boroughs are up.

The clean up after the 2015 explosion. Photo: By MusikAnimal – own work, CC BY-SA 4.0

Butler said the board was not opposed to the law itself, but it was requesting an extension on the deadline to June 30, 2021, along with advance notification and education about which homeowners were affected. “What we are saying is that what was good in 2016 is not necessarily good in 2020.” 

He said the pandemic had put property owners, as well as tenants, in precarious financial situations. When tenants lose their jobs they can’t pay rent, plus landlords themselves may have lost their jobs, and the mortgage still needs to be paid.  “Now suddenly you’ve got to have to get this inspection and pay $600 to $1,000 or more — and that’s just for the inspection. Where am I gonna find this money during COVID?” Butler said.

He said in Bed-Stuy’s Community Board 3, many constituents felt “blindsided and uninformed” and saw it as “another example of City Hall trying to steal property from the Black community.” 

But Department of Buildings press secretary Andrew Rudansky said the implementation details of Local Law 152 were finalized more than a year ago. He said they were “widely communicated” by the department, giving property owners over a year to complete the inspections. “Any property owner with additional questions is encouraged to reach out to us directly.”

A notification from the DOB of when each community board needs to complete its inspection. Photo: DOB

Rudansky said, “as the deadline has gotten closer” the DOB’s community affairs teams had proactively reached out to every elected official and community board, as well as contacting industry stakeholders and publishing reminders on its website and in its newsletter.

However, Butler said Brooklyn Community Board 3 contacted the DOB first, just a couple of months ago, and it was the same situation for Brooklyn Community Board 10.

The city should give property owners a deadline extension, Paul Shay, a Licensed Master Plumber and owner of Bushwick’s A Real Good Plumber said. “I think the city should have given them three months, six months into 2021. This is COVID, this is nuts.”

Shay’s firm had been doing a number of Local Law 152 inspections and only a small percentage of those inspections had presented issues, he said. “And even most of those issues are issues we can just notify the DOB: ‘Let’s get it done over the next six months.”

While the inspections were important to ensure the 2015 incident didn’t repeat itself, Shay said he had emailed a lot of his customers about the deadline, but felt not everyone was aware. “And I think that’s a problem.”

Jessy Edwards

Jessy Edwards is a writer based in Bushwick. Originally from New Zealand, she has written for the BBC, Rolling Stone, NBC New York, CNBC and her hometown newspaper, The Dominion Post, among others.

Join the Conversation


  1. This happened to me except it started with National Grid; they sent in a private plumber to who they contracted out work to. They came to my property and found a coupling on the house meter that needed to be changed so they shut the service down. I contacted my plumber who looked at the work & told me it was called Task 87. It was changed & the next day I called for a turn on. This time a National Grid represenative showed up, the work was inspected and it was approved and service restored. A week or so later another National Grid rep comes by and he tells me that the work was done illegally, they were other problems there blah blah, blah & he calls the city and next thing I know he shuts the city shuts me down and violations are flying. I try to explain the week before National Grid said it was all good but they wouldn’t listen. I never received notice of this Local 152 rule, to me this is a game National Grid & NYC is playing to bring in money and to torture & shakedown small property owners and landlords. It’s a money grab, plain & simple. I was never given that notice by the NYC Dept. of Buildings and now have fines to pay. It’s a joke but hey, all you guys who voted for the idiot in city hall, here you go. And our elected officials are at a loss as to why people are running for the exits from NYC?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.